A smarter way to reduce class size

The NYC Department of Education says that enrollment had decreased this year by nearly 3% — similar to declines elsewhere in the country, due primarily to falling birth rates. But little notice was given to the fact that as of this past September, DOE revealed that 486 schools are still too overcrowded to achieve the smaller classes that are required by law in 2029-2030.

This is only nine fewer schools than the 495 schools that DOE said were too overcrowded to comply in December 2024. Those schools enroll nearly half of all NYC public school students, and at that rate, it would take an estimated 41 years for every school to have enough space for smaller classes.

Currently, there are hundreds of underenrolled schools sitting close to overcrowded ones. If enrollment were balanced between nearby schools over time, it would benefit both overcrowded schools and those currently underenrolled. The latter would be better funded and thus more apt to provide a well-rounded and quality education. As Chancellor Kamar Samuels recently pointed out: “A school that is robustly enrolled … has the capacity to offer advanced coursework, extracurricular activities (and) rigor.”

But in neighborhoods where all schools are overcrowded, there needs to be more capital investment. The city is accelerating development in 12 neighborhoods by bypassing the usual planning process involving Community Boards and the City Council. Our analysis shows that 127 overcrowded schools enrolling more than 105,000 students are located in these same neighborhoods.

In addition, there are large-scale developments already in progress in several parts of the city like Jamaica, Queens and Washington Heights, where many of the schools are already overcrowded, without any apparent plan to address the condition.

There are also plans to move forward with a $1.2 billion redevelopment of Fulton and Elliott-Chelsea public housing in Manhattan, to add roughly 3,500 new units in an area where P.S. 11, one of the local public schools is near capacity, and the other, P.S. 33, is already too overcrowded to lower class size to mandated levels.

In these neighborhoods, there needs to be coordinated planning so that schools are built along with new housing, or even better, as part of these developments, where they could also serve as “anchor tenants” to help finance affordable housing. Moreover, the Educational Construction Fund should be revived. The ECF was created in 1967 to create new schools in mixed development projects, but only fifteen schools have been built by the agency since its inception, and none since 2012.

Finally, nearly three-fourths of the elementary schools too overcrowded to meet the class size mandate offer 3-K and pre-K classes. Shifting some of these classes to nearby Community Based Organizations that have thousands of empty seats and can offer extended day programs for working parents could free up as many as 450 classrooms, with estimated savings in construction costs of as much as $1.7 billion.

Instead of adopting any of these pro-active policies, the latest DOE class size plan makes the following statement: “The city is currently engaging with elected officials at the state level on a proposed SEQRA reform that would carve out public school construction projects from environmental review.” The answer to providing students with the classroom space and smaller classes they deserve is not to expose them to potential environmental harm.

In their rush to create more housing, we urge Mayor Mamdani and his administration not to abandon our public school students. Instead, they deserve a comprehensive and cohesive plan that provides them with the space and smaller classes they need.

Haimson is the executive director of Class Size Matters. Law-Gisiko is president of the City Club, and a former long-time member of Manhattan Community Board 5.