Larry Wilson: Fill up California’s Sites Reservoir

Nine years ago, the editorial board had a visit with Northern California rancher Mary Wells, who spoke in favor of the mammoth Sites Reservoir project to bring new water storage capacity to our drought-prone state.

The thing is, if the reservoir is built, the fifth-generation cattle rancher and rice grower’s home and grazing land —   along with her family’s ancestral cemetery —  would be under 300 feet of water. It would fill up the 14,000-acre Antelope Valley in Colusa County. And yet she still thinks the plan is a good idea.

That shows an incredible dedication to thinking big for the rest of California when big thinking is what we need to avoid a water crisis for future generations.

Back then, she was advocating for using money for Sites from the $7.5 billion Proposition 1 water bond approved by voters  in 2014. When I saw recent news about the project finally getting approval from an important state board, I thought back to that meeting, marveling a bit about how long this thing is taking.

But looking further into it, I see that Sites has actually been under discussion by state and federal authorities since the Eisenhower administration. Nine years is but a small fraction of the time since consideration of the project began.

But earlier this month,  the State Water Resources Control Board voted unanimously to approve what is called a water right permit for the reservoir, a major step forward. If and when construction actually begins, Californians would see two large dams rise to more than 300 feet high, as well as nine smaller ones. They would hold water pumped from the Sacramento River in the valley northwest of Sacramento, near where retired Gov. Jerry Brown lives on his ranch.

Recreational fishing advocates, including the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance and Save California Salmon, are against the plan, arguing the project threatens Chinook salmon, steelhead, sturgeon and Delta smelt while also generally degrading water quality.

I am a trout fisher, and lover of clean water for us and for them, but I support the Sites Reservoir, because we desperately need places to store water.

The Sierra Club is against it, because the group is essentially against building any new dams, and in fact is in favor of tearing down many of the ones we have. I am usually totally on board with all things Sierra Club, but will break with it on Sites. There’s lots of water in the flowing Delta, and we need to capture some of it to sustain California agriculture and ensure there’s enough potable water for Southern Californians and for our gardens. Because there’s actually plenty of water available to our state. It’s just a matter of getting it around.

“We’re living with more extreme droughts and floods, and a growing need to store water during wet periods. Sites is built for exactly that,” water board Chair E. Joaquin Esquivel says, as reported by Ian James in the L.A. Times.

Yes, it’s a $7 billion project. But that’s the kind of investment in water sustainability we need as part of our attempts to adapt to the climate change we have caused.

Gov. Gavin Newsom is on board, saying  the decision shows “California can get big infrastructure projects moving again … Now it’s time to get shovels in the ground.”

Barring lawsuits and the fact that plenty of other obstacles have come up against Sites in the past 70 years, those shovels could begin shoveling next year, with construction estimated to be finished by 2034.

The money is also there. Southern California’s Metropolitan Water District says it will pony up some of our money to help build Sites. $1.3 billion is still available from Prop. 1. Other state and federal monies will pay for about a third of the project. Loans will allow construction to start next spring.

I’m sorry Mary’s beautiful ranch will disappear, yet glad we can still think big.

Larry Wilson is on the Southern California News Group editorial board. lwilson@scng.com