
The Newport Beach City Council on Friday expressed frustration at having to hold a court-ordered special election in March, which will give residents a chance to weigh in on three measures that seek reform and transparency and have sparked much legal wrangling between the city and the resident group that authored them.
“Here we are after multiple back-and-forths, after spending tons of resources, taxpayer dollars, we’re back here again with the potential of not getting what the judicial order is asking us to do because of state law, and two entities have to be participants in this: the state of California and the Secretary of State and the County of Orange Registrar of Voters,” said Councilmember Erik Weigand, who was the sole dissenting vote during a special meeting Friday, Nov. 20, to decide whether to hold the special election. “I’m just not comfortable supporting another call for an election because I don’t think it will be successfully done. It has to be done correctly, and if it’s forced through, it will disenfranchise voters.”
Weigand also added that the city is being forced to schedule the election before the Court of Appeals has had time to look at the city’s challenge to the measures and whether they met requirements to force a public vote.
“With all that, I can’t support putting that on a ballot on March 2, which isn’t a regularly scheduled election,” he said.
Despite Weigand’s opposition, which several other councilmembers said they agreed with on principle, four of the council’s seven members begrudgingly agreed to move forward with the March 2 election date ordered by Orange County Superior Court Judge Julianne Bancroft. Councilmembers Noah Blom and Sara Weber abstained from Friday’s vote.
The city previously chose to call off the special city election Bancroft previously ordered for Nov. 3, just as ballots were supposed to go out.
The three measures — authored by the Newport Beach Stewardship Association — address council term limits, by-district elections and transparency and accountability in the city’s meeting process and records review. Measure P proposes a two-term limit for councilmembers. Measure Q limits district councilmember elections to the area they represent (they are currently voted on by all of the city’s registered voters), and Measure R wants to change elements of the city’s charter regarding public meetings, records, and government oversight and enforcement to ensure transparency.
The Newport Beach Stewardship Association noticed the measures in a publication that, according to city officials, is not Newport Beach’s paper of record. When City Clerk Lena Schumway reviewed them, she questioned the notice, which began a series of legal skirmishes between the city and the stewardship association dating back to June.
But Bancroft ruled that the measures were correctly noticed. That started efforts for a special election — it was too late to consolidate it with the Nov. 3 election, per Bob Page, the Orange County Registrar of Voters so the city was going to have to administer is own special election on the same day as the general election. The city later canceled it when it said it had run out of time and could not get the necessary paperwork and documentation from Page or the secretary of state.
City officials also argued that holding the special election violated the city’s charter and state law.
Schumway said that despite the hurried timeline, she, with the help of an elections consultant, did her best to try and meet the Nov. 3 election order.
The city contracted with election vendors, issued ballots to military and overseas voters, and sought necessary authorization and information from the state and county election officials. Despite those efforts and substantial expenditures, the city could not obtain a ballot-card release or tint and watermark assignment that would permit lawful ballot printing, officials said, or the necessary information concerning certain confidential voters maintained by the registrar.
During Friday’s specially called City Council meeting, Councilmember Joe Stapleton agreed with Weigand that the city has “fought and fought this” and that the process was flawed, but added that he sees no other solution to it other than going through with the March 2 special election, which also meets the deadline of 88 days out the county registrar of voters had for helping with its administration.
“This is a court order; we’re being mandated to hold this,” he said, adding that the situation now is much different than the order to hold the election on Nov. 3, with no county or state support.
Newport Beach City Attorney Aaron Harp confirmed that Page had said he could help with the election.
“We forwarded him a copy of the resolution you’re considering here this afternoon, and he said it satisfied all the requirements for requesting his assistance,” Harp said. “It definitely appears that he will help us with this election on March 2.”
Page also wrote in the email that the council’s resolution must be adopted by Nov. 24 and delivered to the Registrar of Voters no later than Nov. 25. The latter date is also when the measure documents must arrive to be formatted, proofed, and translated for the Voter Information Guide that must hit the printer by Dec. 30 to meet deadlines for issuing ballots to overseas and military voters between Jan. 4 and Jan. 16.
Councilmembers Robyn Grant and Michelle Barto also agreed that they were frustrated with the process the city has gone through, but recognized that Bancroft’s order has to be satisfied.
“There are certain inconsistencies with the election code, perhaps our charter and other state laws, but we definitely have a mandate from the judge, and we are working under the authority of that mandate,” Grant said. “I am uncomfortable about being mandated to have this election, but we need to move forward and resolve this issue.”
Only one person spoke during public comments Friday and asked whether the election would be mail-in only or also include an opportunity for in-person voting.
Page, in an email on Friday, said that he interprets that the Registrar of Voters will mail ballots to all active registered Newport Beach voters and provide official ballot drop boxes and vote centers.
The city will also need to ask the OC Board of Supervisors to authorize Page and his office to provide services for the special election, such as ballot and supporting material preparation, voting equipment, and personnel to receive and process ballots. And the city has about three months to reimburse the county for its costs.
Page said a previous inquiry from the city in October 2025 about what a stand-alone election would have cost for another measure then elicited a cost of $1 million to $1.2 million
“The county’s labor and material costs have increased since that estimate was provided,” he said. ” And the number of pages needed in the voter information guide for Measures P, Q and R will be significantly more than the four pages included in the 2025 cost estimate.”
Records from the Nov. 12 hearing with Judge Bancroft show that the court will set a date for an evidentiary hearing to consider any sanctions and contempt for not having conducted the Nov. 3 election. The court record also indicates that Bancroft will consider the city’s conduct from the “initiation of the lawsuit through the date of the election.”
That date has not yet been set, City Manager Seimone Jurjis said.