
A plan to build a Cape Cod-inspired townhome development replacing a shuttered hospital in Newport Beach was stopped by the City Council this week, which supported an appeal from a nearby nature-inspired school to reject the project.
The proposed Westcliff at Dover project, to be located at 1501 E. 16th St., and to include five three-story buildings with between five and seven condos and garages each, went to the council after an appeal was filed by the Environmental Nature Center. The Planning Commission approved the DR Horton project on June 18.
On June 19, Councilmember Erik Weigand asked the council to review the Planning Commission’s decision.
“The 44-foot height changes the school and preschool’s ambiance,” Weigand said Tuesday, after hearing presentations from both the developer and the director of the school. Weigand noted that both children and adults visit the 50-year-old education center to escape urbanism and seek a more peaceful setting.
“You’ve got a 40-plus-foot building, and no matter what landscape plan comes into fruition, 10-foot setbacks will not allow the landscape envisioned over 10 years to grow,” he said. “I don’t see it ever properly screened. It’s not consistent with various land use issues.”
The city’s housing element identified the site of the former 1950s-era psychiatric hospital as an opportunity to meet state-mandated housing requirements. The developer proposed demolishing the still-standing medical building, which sits on 1.53 acres, and building the for-sale properties. Beyond the nature school, the site’s other neighbors include a church, some ballfields, and the nearby Newport Harbor High School.
In December, the developers submitted their plans to the city.
And, since — and even before then, when in January 2025 they asked for help as trees were being cut down — representatives of the nature school and its preschool have voiced concerns about the development proposed for the site. Among their concerns were the project’s height and its proximity to the school and its nature campus. Key concerns included children’s privacy from balconies and windows that look into the school’s property and outdoor teaching areas. They also worried about shading, noise, and construction traffic.
On Tuesday, representatives from both the development and the school shared their perspectives.
“We are proud and happy to present a single-family residential opportunity for the city of Newport Beach,” said Dan Boyd, vice president of entitlements at DR Horton. “The idea of the project came from the City Council. Each council member should be excited. This is just what you asked for.”
The developer team also included an attorney who told the council the project was “right-sized and consistent with design standards.”
And he reminded the council that the Housing Accountability Act limits its ability to deny or reduce the density of a housing project based on subjective standards, including judgments about its appearance or how it fits into the neighborhood character. He added that “it’s a tough threshold to make” and said the project must be evaluated with objective standards and can be denied or conditioned only as permitted by state law.
He added that fines could be significant and add up to $1.5 million.
“If the council denies the project and we bring suit, the attorney general and the state are going to get involved with that lawsuit,” he warned.
While Weigand and Councilmembers Robyn Grant and Joe Stapleton referenced the possibility of court and state involvement, the council majority, in a 5-0 vote, supported the ENC’s appeal of the Planning Commission decision. They reasoned that the findings needed to support the project approval were missing, including the requested objective development standard waivers.
“My biggest fear is Sacramento starts mandating everything we do here as a community,” said Stapleton, who abstained from the vote. “I do not support this project where it is today, and I’m convinced this is heading to a courtroom.”
Mayor Lauren Kleiman recused herself and left the dais at the start of the discussion, citing a personal conflict.
Grant, a former land-use attorney, acknowledged that a prior council had worked on the city’s housing plan, which identified this site as a possibility.
“We formulated our approach for the mandate much differently than other cities,” she said. “We managed it with buffers and overlays, and the buffers were meant to take into account that overlays were not site-specific. If a project didn’t work in a specific site, we didn’t want to be out of compliance.”
“Now, we’ve manipulated the process of overlays,” she added. “We do have some discretion, and most of it relates to objective standards and making sure they are properly applied.”
Grant said site constraints matter at this location.
“We have a project that’s directly adjacent to a preschool serving young children, a nature center that is an essential resource in our community,” she said. “So, we want to be sensitive to property rights and those rights as well. I felt the project record and findings did fail to substantiate development at the location, density, and configuration provided. And it does create some adverse impacts on health and safety.”
She cited concerns over a lack of building separation, excessive mass and scale, and limited setbacks.
“And the compromised emergency access, all items we have given waivers for,” she said. “I do think that those impact the public health and safety, and they’re things we need to relook at and come to some agreement on.”
She made a last-ditch suggestion that the two sides try once more to hash out their differences, but Bo Glover, director of the ENC, wasn’t open to the idea.
“We’ve been at the table a long time,” he said. “Regardless of the dialogue you’ve heard, DR Horton isn’t coming to the table. We’re not willing to go back to the table unless they can give us two stories and proper setbacks.”
With no agreement to continue discussions, Grant withdrew her motion for a continuance. The council is set to make a resolution declaring the project dead at its Dec. 8 meeting.
“This is an extraordinary moment for the Environmental Nature Center and the community that has supported us for more than five decades,” Glover said on Thursday following the decision. “We are deeply grateful to the City Council for listening to the concerns of the community and recognizing the importance of protecting this special place. This outcome demonstrates what can happen when people come together to advocate for something they believe in.”